Home Writers Writing Groups Contests Link | Invite | Help  

The downside of technology in literary criticism


A Story by Neva Bryan
"
Hoffman and the critics
"

When author Alice Hoffman read Roberta Silman’s review of her novel The Story Sisters, the author was not pleased. The review wasn’t stellar but certainly it wasn’t crushing. Hoffman, however, chose to respond in less than gracious fashion.

She tweeted nasty comments about Silman and the Boston Globe, and published Silman’s e-mail and phone number. Apparently that last action was meant as a call to arms: Hoffman fans of the world, unite! Tell off this critic!

Having been a Hoffman fan for many years, I do not feel a sense of unity with any other fan who might have chosen to answer that call before the author withdrew the tweets and issued a tepid apologetic statement.

I’m more inclined to be less inclined to read any future Hoffman books. Had she played the proverbial wet duck, she would be a much more sympathetic figure. Instead, she comes off as a hothouse flower.

There’s a danger in using technology as reprisal. Sometimes it backfires. Anyone who’s ever made a drunken phone call to an ex in the middle of the night knows how it works. Technology used in the heat of the moment equals regret, regret, regret.


© 2009 Neva Bryan



Share Writer Stats
MySpace Bulletin
Share on MySpace
Facebook
Friendster
Orkut
Hi5
Wordsy
Add to Library
Bookmark Story
Email to Friends
Link
[more]








My Review

Would you like to review this Story?
Login | Register


Featured Review

So true. So true. Technology killed the thought process. "Think it through" is what I always say. Of course, I had to think about that before I thought it through. ;) Anyway, good point. Another thing that bothers me are those people that block you because you give them what they think is a negative review. If it is malicious I can understand that, but to give constructive criticism in a tasteful manner is another. Especially when they then get mad at you and send you a scathing message and then block you (before you can even reply if you should choose to do so). Technology. Pros and cons I guess.

Posted 5 Months Ago

1 of 1 people found this review constructive.


Loading..