This is pretty much a raw draft of nonsense haha.
But its something that I felt the need to write after having to emotionally deal with the loss of someone.
I appreciate any honest opinions & criticism from anyone.
I notice that the key emotion stays stationary throughout the whole piece; i think that may be because you were writing in only one stage of loss. There are a good deal of stages of people's reactions to loss; basically just denial, depression/hysteria, and acceptance/resignation, in that order. Obviously the stage you were portraying was between depression and resignation, but even within those solid stages, there's a lot of different shades of gray. Although the poem as a whole is truly beautiful and open, it could improve even more if you amplified some more of your points of view, or ways of dealing with the loss.
It's never easy to write about loss; when we write about it, we try to search for the honesty, the feelings we have, so that we can get it all out and express it..but the problem is that until you're fully over the loss, you won't be able to write everything you feel about it.
But goddamn, this has sure got some hardcore emotion. That last part where you talk about all the things that can never happen anymore is definitely where you tie in your audience. The only thing about that part is that in trying to structure it as you did, i think you limited yourself. If you were more liberal in the structure of that stanza, the pathos appeal could be way stronger.
I like that ending quote, it's a good note to tie it all in with; the audience can't know for sure whose it is..we want it to be from the intended audience, but at the same time we don't want anything to do with him because we sympathize with our speaker, so it provides something bittersweet to make us think.
I don't like that very last line, though. If you wanted to keep it for sure, then I think it would be better without that elipsis, but that line is so summarizational, and what it says is implied so strongly throughout the poem. I think it would just end perfectly without that very last line.
Or, if you're really set on keeping it, maybe restructure it or something, keep the bit about the promise.
I notice that the key emotion stays stationary throughout the whole piece; i think that may be because you were writing in only one stage of loss. There are a good deal of stages of people's reactions to loss; basically just denial, depression/hysteria, and acceptance/resignation, in that order. Obviously the stage you were portraying was between depression and resignation, but even within those solid stages, there's a lot of different shades of gray. Although the poem as a whole is truly beautiful and open, it could improve even more if you amplified some more of your points of view, or ways of dealing with the loss.
It's never easy to write about loss; when we write about it, we try to search for the honesty, the feelings we have, so that we can get it all out and express it..but the problem is that until you're fully over the loss, you won't be able to write everything you feel about it.
But goddamn, this has sure got some hardcore emotion. That last part where you talk about all the things that can never happen anymore is definitely where you tie in your audience. The only thing about that part is that in trying to structure it as you did, i think you limited yourself. If you were more liberal in the structure of that stanza, the pathos appeal could be way stronger.
I like that ending quote, it's a good note to tie it all in with; the audience can't know for sure whose it is..we want it to be from the intended audience, but at the same time we don't want anything to do with him because we sympathize with our speaker, so it provides something bittersweet to make us think.
I don't like that very last line, though. If you wanted to keep it for sure, then I think it would be better without that elipsis, but that line is so summarizational, and what it says is implied so strongly throughout the poem. I think it would just end perfectly without that very last line.
Or, if you're really set on keeping it, maybe restructure it or something, keep the bit about the promise.
Oh, I can just feel the sorrow in this poem! When we're lucky enough to find someone who will turn our lives into a wonderful dream, its a very special thing. Unfortunately in this wicked world, nightmares do rear their ugly heads. I'm so sorry for your loss. I hope writing this helped you, its certainly inspired me. Beautiful job. :-)
I'm a writer & a very green one at that. I almost feel like I'm admitting to something I've done wrong haha...
but I write because it's a need for me, like needing to breathe I need to write.
My imagi.. more..