The number 4, and Tiffany Stratton's alcohol

It would pretend.

Like a cherished bad boy, it would pretend.

Of the numbers, 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5, the number 4 would pretend.

You see, just like being a CBB, the number 4 was in fact a CBBC.

The number 4 was sexuality.

(&, indeed, as sexuality, had an ideological agenda to use its CBBC status - secret status; the other numbers didn't know abut 4's ulterior - in order to meet up with its real CBBC partner, Tiffany Stratton of the WWE, as its own CBB self)

The other numbers.

They were able to cotton on (no pun intended), to 4's agenda, via the methodology of CBB (cherished bad boy) also being the natural segway to another CBB - check mate.

So no: number 4 didn't get the bottle of alcohol, to share with Tiffy Time