This is really touching; in a very skillful way you show the innocence and the pain and the hesitancy of love. Villanelle is a very hard form to work with, and it usually turns out to be crude and forced, but your poem flows well and emanataes with good feelings. Great work!
The rhyme & rhythm oozing with emotions,is so comforting...it calls for so much of warmth & security..this was a new form for me & I enjoyed it thoroughly..
The villanelle is a lovely and powerful form- you handled it beautifully here, Allan. The repetition frames a story of determination and living up to past promises. May the author indeed find the wherewithal to return one day to what was stated.
Posted 11 Years Ago
There is such a recurring music in your voice that translates pretty things on paper ....
This is romantic and conveys a yearning to restart an old flame...one that will never be forgotten.
What a lovely, sad, and beautiful display...heartfelt!
"Dreams of embraces are miles apart.
We shared our youth on that first fateful day,
I promise my love I’ll return for your heart."~Nicely done, my friend.~xoxo~:)
It is fun to read when people experiment..it gives us knowledge of styles & reminds us ..it is ok to give something different a go... I think you did a great job! Thank you for sharing ! ( :
Very nice, Sir! I am always sincerely flattered when someone attempts something because he had liked something I'd done...particularly when he does it so well, and seemingly effortlessly! My emulation of "markymark", after all, was what inspired me to undertake the Villanelle, as was my writing of two sestinas my paean to a Louisiana friend named Travis. I liked your response to Angi: "that's how we grow", and I think that she may have had a point about "we'll" versus "will". "Our paths will rechart" suggests that something is going to happen TO the paths, whereas, "Our paths we'll rechart" more actively indicates something WE (whose antecedent is OUR, after all) are going to do. I'd also like to see the clause "my love" set off either by commas, or a comma and a colon, as "I'll return for your heart" IS the promise made TO "my love". But trivial punctuation considerations notwithstanding, this is a fine, a lovely and a noteworthy verse, and its being your first makes it even more so!
Posted 12 Years Ago
11 Years Ago
Of course Mark I answered this in full and then the computer conked out on me and I lost everything... read moreOf course Mark I answered this in full and then the computer conked out on me and I lost everything....so I know I won't hit all the points the same way, but here goes..
1st point was will vs. we'll....never thought of we'll but now I am...though it really does change the meaning... will (being done by) vs. we'll (being done to)...I like the affect of both...but I'll decide at another time...though I am leaning toward "we'll"...similar reasoning "to your heart" vs. "for your heart"...
Do I simply want to find my way to your heart and hope "you" let me in or do I actively want to reach your heart and " take"it, if "you" are still interested? I don't know, just asking. "to" just seems too noncommittal, "for" indicates commitment. Comma would def. work. I'll decide later. Thanks for all your thoughtful and helpful insight Mark. Allen
Allen, I really like this. I have also been thinking about attempting Villanelle. I have a germ of an idea that keeps sliding just out of my reach. I read this 3 times and in the 5th stanza, I kept saying, 'Palpable landings and paths WE'LL rechart. I hope you don't mind me telling you that. Anyway, lovely work.
Posted 12 Years Ago
12 Years Ago
Thanks Angi for your comments... I do appreciate them...
I'm not quite sure of your critique b.. read moreThanks Angi for your comments... I do appreciate them...
I'm not quite sure of your critique bout "will" vs. "well" however... but it was intended to be will. As in our "paths will rechart". perhaps you can expound upon that a little, so I better understand what you're alluding to....
and absolutely NO, I will never mind constructive criticism and reviews. Feel free to say anything and point out anything you see. Offer suggestions as well. I may not always agree...but sometimes I certainly do. It's the way we get better.
allen
12 Years Ago
My mouth kept saying, ...landings and paths we'll rechart. Like we will do this together. Somethin.. read moreMy mouth kept saying, ...landings and paths we'll rechart. Like we will do this together. Something with the flow, I think. Not so much a critique as telling you how my mind kept reading it, if that makes sense. I should have kept my trap shut! Ha!
Not at all...Now I get it..If I saw the apostrophe, it would have made sense..as it is, it makes a g.. read moreNot at all...Now I get it..If I saw the apostrophe, it would have made sense..as it is, it makes a good deal of sense...actually, I don't know...I'll have to think about we'll....sota like it.....we'll see
but for now....
thanks...very helpful
allen
12 Years Ago
Anytime. I have a feeling I will see you around. Have a good evening, Allen.
I'm a poet, a singer, a peaceful gunslinger..
looking to share my poetry..and a little bit of me...if I dare
I 've been writing since I was 18.... am slightly older now, and still trying to fin.. more..